I was the man those women talked about.

Last summer I volunteered [for a PVP storytelling event], and hearing those women speak is the reason I’m here telling my abortion story tonight.

Some backstory for you: I was raised by a single mom in Sandpoint in the late 70s/early 80s. As a girl and young woman in Spokane in the fifties, she’d been raised to be in a sorority and marry well, if nothing else. While educated, liberal, supportive of civil rights and gay marriage, she was raised with very clear gender roles that were imparted to me, in which the image of the ideal male she imprinted on me was a sort of highly athletic college professor version of the bodice ripper. Which is a quaint way to say, I was raised in a climate in which the male was expected to be pushy for sex, while the woman was somehow supposed to be passionate and sexual but also somehow at fault for unwanted pregnancies. 

During the last few years, as a father who has co-parented a couple of people out into the world, as an environmentalist, as a critic of inequality, I’ve been fortunate to learn about how western European gender perspectives were shaped during the colonial era, and in order to avoid abstracting into a discussion of coloniality, let me just say our social order is based on a deliberate effort on the part of the ruling class to “other” anything and everything that is not wealthy, white, and cis-male. The specter of out and out state support for race and gender discrimination has risen since Ferguson, really. And at this time, Idaho as a state, as an administrative/bureaucratic institution, is among the most blatant and unapologetic expressions of the womb as male property in the world.

When I was here last summer, all the speakers were women. And I feel like it was the first time I actually heard what it was like for the impregnated person. The person growing the fetus. If there was a common theme running through the stories told that night, it was that the men who impregnated them had an assumption of control over the pregnancy: it was their decision, and talking about keeping the baby made them angry or worse. I don’t honestly remember the details of the individual stories because I was so overwhelmed recognizing myself as the man they were talking about. 

I was in several committed, live-in relationships during my twenties, and as the son of a single mother, I understood the cycle. I knew I didn’t want kids, and I knew I was fertile, and I thought it was, I don’t know… ok, acceptable, valiant even? to push for penetrational sex. To expect it. As the son of a woman who was raped, I do know that no means no, no. But I was much more immediately responsive to “it’s not safe right now,” if you know what I mean. And we all know how well that works, right? Like, most of the time.

So, in addition to all the other soft landings being a white male has offered, when I “unexpectedly” impregnated someone I was in a long-term relationship with, abortion was the expected solution. I don’t want to make it sound like I didn’t experience the emotional consequences so much as to say, until last summer, I thought I had “lived through” the cycle of missed periods that ends in abortion as a feminist, basically, or at least a supporter of feminism. Like, at least I voted right and wore the right t-shirts or whatever. 

But I was the man those women talked about. And what I really understand now is how prevalent that kind of experience of men is for women. Even the most feminist of men can, at that moment of shared responsibility for a growing fetus, lean on a cultural hierarchy that still sees the womb as a resource. That erases the bearer of the womb.

Not only did the stories awaken my own memories of being the impregnator in an abortion, it also connected the stories I was hearing to the women in my life I love. And I can’t stand the thought of anyone, for any reason, experiencing erasure. If you have daughters you love, imagine someone they love silencing their voice, disrespecting their autonomy, their right to self-determination. 

Right now, Idaho as a bureaucratic apparatus is dedicated to preventing women from making decisions about their own bodies. And I want to recognize in myself that I leaned on the same sort of hierarchy of human value that is required in order for such discrimination to exist. Our social order is built on it, but it is untenable.

I have had many chances to think about abortion and reproductive rights, and I have always supported the right to choose. Or so I thought, until I heard those stories last summer.

Thank you

Previous
Previous

17 year-old me had no idea what was coming

Next
Next

My views have changed.